Vitamin D3 Revisited – One Size Does Not Fit All

by | Apr 23, 2020

Are you confused about how much Vitamin D3 you need and when? You are not alone. Read what scientists recently have to say about what an individual may need to achieve optimum D status.

 New Research

Nearly every cell in the body contains a vitamin D receptor. Research shows vitamin D plays an important role in skeletal, immune, developmental and cardiovascular health. Thus, maintaining optimal vitamin D levels is vital for overall health.

A Long Term Vitamin D3 Debate

A heated debate surrounds the recommended vitamin D dosage and levels. While many nutrition scientists advise  that adults take 5000 IU of vitamin D3 daily, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) established 4000 IU daily as the tolerable upper level of intake, meaning the highest level unlikely to cause harm in nearly all adults. On the other hand, the Endocrine Society Practice Guidelines state that up to 10,000 IU of vitamin D3 daily is safe for most adults. These conflicting recommendations can leave the public confused.

Dr. Brouse’s NOTE:

It is interesting that scientists are encouraged to question  any dogmatic statement such as, “You can get all the nutrients you need from eating three healthy meals per day.”  Science constantly questions theories and conclusions based upon new and emerging data.  The history of allopathic medicine dictates doctrine to students and discourages questioning medical theories.  The ongoing debates surrounding the rediscovery of the uniqueness of vitamin D3 continues to be negatively portrayed by a medical/drug/food/agribusiness lobby with vested interests to keep the status quo intact.  Shrouded in the cloak of “skepticism to safeguard the public” classical medicine has shunned nutrition but approved smoking cigarettes, eating sugar and taking foreign chemicals into our body without substantial science to back their endorsements.

So, What Is The Truth?

In order to begin to see a statistical health benefit from taking vitamin D3, a blood level of 40 ng/ml (100 nm/L) is required.  In order to gain adequate prevention of the listed diseases a person must maintain a blood level above 60 ng/ml (150 nm/L) based upon the research of the Garland brothers at the Mayo clinic.

 How Much Vitamin D3 Is Too Much? Researchers Conducted A Study In Search Of The Answer.

A total of 3,882 participants were included in the study. The average age of the participants was 60 years old. Less than 1% of the participants were considered underweight, 35.5% had a normal BMI, 37.0% were overweight and 27.5% were obese.

At the beginning of the study, 55% of the participants reported taking vitamin D. The average dose of vitamin D increased from 2,106 IU daily at the beginning of the study to 6,767 IU daily about one year later. The average vitamin D levels increased from 34.8 ng/ml to 50.4 ng/ml during this time (p < 0.001).

What Is The Best Dosage For Vitamin D3?

The researchers wanted to determine the dosage needed to achieve healthy vitamin D levels, as defined by levels of 40 ng/ml or higher. They also wanted to determine the incidence of side effects, including hypercalcemia. Here is what the researchers found:
Change in vitamin D levels were influenced by vitamin D dosage, body mass index (BMI) and vitamin D levels at the beginning of the study.
Participants who were vitamin D deficient (< 20 ng/ml) at baseline experienced greater increases in vitamin D levels than those with insufficient or sufficient vitamin D levels at baseline. Participants without vitamin D deficiency at baseline experienced a blunted response to the same vitamin D dose compared to someone with vitamin D deficiency. Response to vitamin D supplementation was less with increasing BMI. In other words, obese individuals required the greatest supplementation to achieve sufficient levels, and normal weight or underweight required the least supplementation to achieve sufficient levels. Vitamin D3 intakes of at least 6,000 IU daily were required for those with a normal BMI to achieve a vitamin D status above 40 ng/ml.

Size Matters

Overweight participants required vitamin D3 intakes of at least 7,000 IU daily to achieve a vitamin D status above 40 ng/ml. Obese participants required vitamin D3 intakes of at least 8,000 IU daily to achieve a vitamin D status above 40 ng/ml. Average calcium levels did not differ from the beginning of the study to the end of the study. A subgroup of participants (285) did not experience significant increases in vitamin D status despite reporting taking substantial intakes of vitamin D (> 4,000 IU daily). The researchers determined that gastrointestinal issues were likely attributed to the malabsorption but non-compliance undoubtedly played a role as well. (For example, the rate of non-compliance with antihypertensive medication is about 30%.)
Twenty new cases of hypercalcemia occurred between the beginning of the study and the end. Those with vitamin D levels below 40 ng/ml were more likely to experience hypercalcemia than those with vitamin D levels of 40 ng/ml or higher.

Can You Take Too Much Vitamin D3?

The researchers were also interested in whether vitamin D supplementation led to an increased incidence of hypercalciuria, high calcium levels in the urine. It is thought that excessively high vitamin D levels may cause hypercalciuria. However, the researchers found that the incidence of hypercalciuria actually declined after vitamin D supplementation, starting with a total of 67 hypercalciuric cases but at follow-up 67% were no longer hypercalciuric.

Furthermore, it’s important to point out that none of the participants developed any evidence for clinical vitamin D toxicity, which consists of hypercalcemia and 25(OH)D> 200 ng/ml, fatigue, anorexia, abdominal pain, frequent urination, irritability, excessive thirst, nausea and sometimes vomiting.  Vitamin D3 is 50 times safer than the prescription vitamin D2 used for over  50 years by doctors and used to fortify dairy and cereal products.

Biochemical vitamin D toxicity consists of 25(OH)D >200 ng/ml, hypercalcemia and a suppressed PTH level with no clinical symptoms, but none of the participants had that either.

Because most labs identify the normal range for 25(OH)D at 30-100 ng/ml, some physicians believe any 25(OH)D above 100 ng/ml is toxicity. It is not; it is usually just hypervitaminosis D.  Healthy individuals who I have followed  show blood levels between 60 and 125 ng/ml.  I had one patient who had been self treating with massive doses of vitamin D3 who tested a blood level of 236 ng/ml with no signs or symptoms of toxicity. Researchers conclude a very wide margin of safety with the bioidentical vitamin D3 .

The researchers concluded,

“Doses of vitamin D in excess of 6,000 IU/d were required to achieve serum 25(OH)D concentrations above 100 nmol/L [40 ng/ml], especially in individuals who were overweight or obese without any evidence of toxicity.”

One thing that the authors didn’t mention is the role genetics may play in this. For example, the gene that codes for the 25-hydroxylase has a genetically determined variation in its transcription. Some people have more 25-hydroxylase than others and thus will obtain higher 25(OH)D levels than others.

While the authors did not stress it, these subjects had repeated vitamin D levels drawn. Given these findings, keeping the genetics in mind, the only way to be sure you are > 40 ng/ml is to get a 25(OH)D test. Testing

[highlight]Remember, “What gets measured gets managed,” so start managing your health with Dr. Brouse and invest in your future with a Build A Better You nutritional analysis and program schedule every year around your birthday.  You can rest assured health is in your future.[/highlight]

Wholesome ~ Fresh ~ Delicious                                                                                                    A Cookbook From The Brouse House

Wholesome ~ Fresh ~ Delicious A Cookbook From The Brouse House

JENNIE BROUSE has a passion for making delicious, nutritious food, and has been practicing since she was a girl. Her dear mother instilled in her the wisdom of eating for health, growing and preserving food from their large garden, and cooking from scratch. This lifestyle continued while raising their children to today. Sharing her delicious meals with friends and family has been part of her “love language”. Jennie’s husband, Richard, has counseled many patients with nutritional advice for over 43 years. She has worked beside him encouraging them in their change to a healthier lifestyle, including eating habits. This cookbook has evolved from the many requests of patients and friends who want a few guidelines for more wholesome cooking. Thus, Wholesome-Fresh-Delicious has been created with recipes that have been favorites in the Brouse house. It is the authors’ hope that many will be inspired to seek out more wholesome food sources, embrace seasonal eating of fresh produce, and love cooking from scratch; all of which will encourage great health!

Tinnitus – Stop That Ringing

Tinnitus – Stop That Ringing

Nutrition can play a great part in contorlling ringing in the ears Rarely, tinnitus is due to an actual sound, such as blood rushing through an enlarged vein—a problem that requires medical treatment. More commonly the problem is due to nerve irritation from an...

Prevent Falling Down

Prevent Falling Down

The best ways to prevent falls! What do some medications, inner ear problems, foot pain, weight changes, blood sugar issues and vitamin D deficiency have in common? They can all affect your balance. And when you’re an older adult, being just the slightest bit off...

MetSys Wellness Evaluation

The MetSys program measures your current nutritional status and makes any suggestions to optimize your nutritional possibilities. With a comprehensive evaluation of your blood and urine profile, diet, and lifestyle symptoms, a report will be produced giving personalized recommendations.

Live Tele-Clinics

Join Our Free Tele-Clinics

Tele-Clinic are hosted weekly every Tuesday and Thursday 3:30 p.m. Pacific Standard Time, registration required. 

Dr. Richard Brouse Retd.

Dr. Brouse is a widely-recognized authority in the fields of nutrition and prevention of chronic degenerative diseases. He follows the practice of natural nutrition and lifestyle espoused by a number of pioneers in the field such as Linus Pauling, Abram Hoffer, Robert Cathcart, James Duke, and Evan Shute. He is an effective teacher with the ability to communicate scientific information in a manner that the general public can understand and apply.

Learn more

Office Hours

7:30am - 3:30pm PST
Tuesday and Thursday
Call Julie at 503.631.4184

Customer Hotline

Call (971) 978-9155 every Tuesday & Thursday 8:00 a.m. – 9:30 a.m. PST

Hot Line is complimentary service for clients currently on a program with Dr. Brouse.


All search results
Share This